West Allis man charged in wife Erica Carpenter’s 2024 death

Benjamin Carpenter, 45, of West Allis, Wisconsin, was arrested on Tuesday, November 17, and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in the death of his 40-year-old wife.

For two years, Erica Carpenter’s death looked like a terrible accident, but police now say they found probable cause to believe that Benjamin planned and caused it instead.

When police and firefighters arrived at the couple’s home in October 2024, they found Erica at the bottom of the basement stairs, bleeding from the head. Her husband Benjamin was performing CPR.

According to the criminal complaint, Benjamin told authorities that Erica had fallen and struck her head while the couple was doing laundry. He added that he then tried to carry her upstairs and slipped, and that they both fell as a result.

“Her injuries didn’t match his account”

However, the medical examiner told police that Erica’s injuries didn’t match his account.

Toxicology tests later found both hydrocodone and a sleep medication in her system. Her official cause of death was listed as undetermined, but the deputy chief medical examiner indicated that she may have died from asphyxia, noting a blunt force injury to her neck. The complaint says investigators questioned Benjamin about his background as a jiu-jitsu black belt, and his experience with techniques including choke holds.

“Texts about her water”

Investigators also found text messages from the weeks before Erica died, in which she asked her husband if he had been putting a powdery substance in her water.

According to prosecutors, Benjamin was in a relationship with another woman prior and following Erica’s death. That woman told authorities that Benjamin had said the weekend Erica died that he and his wife planned to separate.

After Erica’s death, Benjamin collected more than $200,000 from life insurance policies, along with her workplace benefits, while also promoting a now-deactivated GoFundMe campaign to help pay for her funeral.

The complaint says he told police he was unsure about the insurance through her employer, but the employer told investigators he had already been in contact with them about it. Police cited his Google searches as part of the evidence.

Erica’s parents say they have been left stunned by the charge, and that they now want justice for their daughter.

Benjamin made his first court appearance on Wednesday, while his attorney did not respond to requests for comment. Police are asking anyone with information about Erica’s death to contact the West Allis Police Department.

 

Read more about...