Warning: This article contains discussion of subjects some readers may find distressing.
A British woman who travelled thousands of miles to the US has been described in court as the victim of a chilling plot allegedly orchestrated by a man who prosecutors say manipulated and groomed her before killing her.
Dwain Hall, 54, is accused of murdering 32-year-old Sonia Exelby after allegedly luring her from her home in Portsmouth, UK, to Florida under the promise that he would end her life.
Prosecutors claim Hall demanded $4,000 (£3,000) from Exelby in exchange for carrying out the act, with the court hearing that he had exploited her mental health struggles for what one prosecutor described as his own “sadistic pleasure”.
The details have emerged during Hall’s trial in Ocala, Florida, where he is facing charges of first-degree murder and kidnapping. If convicted, he could spend the rest of his life in prison.
Exelby, a classically trained musician, was found dead in a shallow grave in Marion County on October 17, 2025, just days after travelling to the United States.
Prosecutors say men were ‘competing’ to kill Sonia
Jurors have heard that Exelby had struggled with mental illness for much of her life and had expressed a desire to die.
According to prosecutors, she had been looking for an outlet that would make her feel something again, with Assistant State Attorney Amy Berndt telling the court that her vulnerability was allegedly exploited.
The pair reportedly met through a fetish website, where Hall used the username ‘Alpha Sadist’.
Berndt said Hall had allegedly been manipulating Exelby for years after they first began communicating.
“He targeted her because of her mental illness and he exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure,” she told the court.
“And when he finally got her alone, thousands of miles away from home, completely incapable of making any rational decisions, he stabbed her to death and buried her body.”
The court also heard that Exelby had exchanged messages with numerous men on the website, which has since been shut down, in the hope of finding someone who would kill her.
Berndt said Exelby had been searching for “some substitute” for self-harm and described the situation as deeply disturbing.
“Unfortunately, she found another outlet…about two years before her death, and ultimately that outlet would lead to her murder,” the prosecutor said.
According to the prosecution, there was no shortage of men willing to carry out the act, with Berndt telling jurors that some were effectively competing for the opportunity.
Dwain Hall allegedly ‘won the job’ of being her executioner
In a particularly chilling description of the alleged arrangement, Berndt told the court that Hall had gradually manipulated Exelby until he became the person she trusted to carry out the plan.
“One man won out,” jurors were told.
“One man would manipulate and groom Sonia until he won the job of being her executioner. That person was the defendant Dwain Hall.”
Prosecutors allege Hall had initially arranged to meet Exelby and carry out the plan in March last year, although the meeting did not go ahead.
They claim that after this fell through, Hall decided he could make money from the arrangement.
“He told her that she had to bring 4,000 dollars with her when she actually came here for him to kill her,” Berndt said.
“Ultimately, he says he helped Sonia get what she wanted.”
However, prosecutors allege that when Exelby eventually travelled to Florida, Hall stabbed her and buried her body.
A post-mortem examination reportedly found four stab wounds on the left side of her body. The wounds were between four and seven inches deep and had struck vital structures, the court heard.
Hall denies murdering the British woman
Hall has denied the charges against him.
His defence lawyer told the jury that they believed the evidence would ultimately show that Hall was not responsible for Exelby’s death.
“We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case, you will arrive at the decision that Dwain Hall did not murder.”
The trial is ongoing, and the allegations made by prosecutors have yet to be proven in court.
If you have been affected by any of the issues discussed in this article and need someone to talk to, you do not have to face things alone. If you’re in the United States and need emotional support, you can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. It is free, confidential, and available 24/7.
Read more: