Chris Watts’ ex-fiancée Lizzie Henderson breaks silence

Chris Watts’ former fiancée has broken her silence about their failed engagement, saying her relationship with the convicted killer became a “danger” as she teased “there is so much more” to the story.

In 2018, Chris Watts murdered his pregnant wife, Shanann, and their two daughters, Bella, 4, and Celeste, 3, later admitting he wanted to start a new life with his mistress, Nichol Kessinger.

Sentenced to five consecutive life terms (three of them consecutive) Watts is now locked up at Dodge Correctional Institution, the maximum-security prison for men in Wisconsin, where his love life has continued attracting attention.

And, despite the brutality of his crimes, the killer dad still receives letters from women. Meanwhile, reports have surfaced alleging he has developed intimate relationships with male inmates.

“Younger guys flock to Chris,” a prison worker told the Daily Mail. “He’s really got a hold over them and they’ll usually do whatever he wants.”

“When I say these guys will do anything for him, I mean anything,” the anonymous employee added.

But Watts’ relationships behind bars haven’t been limited to fellow inmates.

Moved to Wisconsin

Lizzie Henderson, a former real estate agent from Ohio, reportedly visited Watts at least 20 times throughout 2025, with the couple even exchanging kisses and declarations of love during a Christmas Day visit.

Henderson also relocated to Wisconsin, although she insists the move had nothing to do with Watts.

“I chose to work here, I did not come out here for Chris,” she told the Daily Mail.

“I got a promotion to come out here,” said Henderson, who works at a grocery store about two hours from the prison where Watts is serving time.

‘There is so much more’

Their wedding plans eventually fell apart, but Henderson  – who according to FoxNews had legally changed her name to Lizzie Watts – has offered little explanation for the split.

When Daily Mail reporters caught up with her at her grocery store, the diamond ring she once wore was gone, although a tattoo resembling a wedding band remained on her finger.

She initially said she was “doing good,” but her mood changed when the conversation turned to Watts.

“A lot of stuff happened after,” she said of the publicity surrounding their engagement. “There is so much more to it.”

The attention surrounding her relationship had apparently taken a toll, and Henderson was unwilling to revisit the experience.

“I don’t want to talk about anything about that because that really put me in a really bad light,” she said, emphasizing her religious beliefs. “The reason why I do anything I do is for God – 100% – no matter who it is.”

‘A danger to me’

But while Henderson declined to explain exactly why the engagement ended, she made it clear that the reaction to their relationship had been frightening.

“Talking to someone about God was not a danger to me – what happened was a danger to me,” she said.

“The kind of things I got sent would have scared the average person. My belief in God is that strong,” she added, refusing to elaborate.

 

Read more about...